skip to main content

NLS logo

  • Using the Library
  • Digital resources
  • Catalogues
  • News & events
  • Shop
  • Contact
  • Register/Log in
  • Home
  • Exhibitions
  • Treasures
  • Blackwood's Magazine
  • Controversies

Lawsuits and controversy

Special announcement
Special announcement link >
  • Treasures
Detail from a summons of damages against William Blackwood
Summons of damages against
William Blackwood, 1817.

After 'Blackwood's Magazine' relaunched in October 1817, the magazine developed a reputation for scandal with its critical essays and reviews.

Sir Walter Scott reviewed Mary Shelley's 'Frankenstein' in 'Blackwood's', and raised concerns about its subject matter. His overall impression of the book was baffled bewilderment, and he wondered why it had to be written at all.

Alongside critical essays, the magazine became known for personal attacks on public figures, which triggered a number of lawsuits against the magazine.

 

'Libellous publication'

In November 1817, John Graham Dalyell submitted a summons of damages against William Blackwood. The document accused Blackwood of 'wicked, false, calumnious and libellous publication' which rendered Dalyell's 'person, character and occupations […] the subject of ridicule, obloquy and reproach'.

 

The summons of damages is on display in '"Blackwood's" at 200', at the Library from 30 March to 2 July 2017.

About this site

  • Site map
  • Guides for users
  • Site accessibility
  • Privacy
  • Use of cookies
  • Copyright

Quick links

  • Subject A-Z list
  • Family history
  • Online maps
  • Digital gallery
  • Moving Image Archive
  • Academic research

Practical information

  • Opening hours
  • Location map
  • Visitor Centre Edinburgh
  • Kelvin Hall
  • Copying services

Stay informed

  • RSS news feed
  • Email newsletter
  • Social networking
  • Publications

About us

  • About us
  • Working at the Library
  • Support us
  • Corporate documents
  • Freedom of information
  • Procurement

© 2018 National Library of Scotland