National Library of Scotland
Black and white image of two women and the book cover of Scotch Verdict by Lillian Faderman.

This Pride month, join researcher Indigo Dunphy-Smith to revisit the history of a famous Edinburgh scandal that saw two Edinburgh schoolmistresses accused of lesbianism. The early 19th-century legal case ended with the uniquely Scottish verdict: not proven.

Marianne Woods and Jane Pirie, the two accused women, faced professional ruin regardless. The case reveals deep anxieties about intimacy and desire between women. It highlights what could be said - and by whom - when such relationships existed in legal ambiguity.

Two hundred years later, the case still haunts our culture. Indigo will show how its silences and contradictions have inspired interpretations from Scotland to Hollywood. In this talk, you can decide what really happened.

About the speaker

Indigo Dunphy-Smith (she/her) is a researcher and writer based in Edinburgh. She specialises in telling queer stories in historic places and is the author of 'How to: Queer Your Historic House'. With over eight years in the heritage sector, she regularly delivers talks on Scotland's queer history and co-chairs the National Trust for Scotland's LGBTQ network.

You may be interested in

An accusation of a Lesbian affair in 19th century Scotland

A short video introducing the story of schoolteachers Marianne Woods and Jane Pirie.
A photo of Alex Wilson behind text that says 'The Warping of History'.

The 1911 census boycott in Scotland

Talk
16 April 2026, 5:30PM to 6:30PM
Bookshelves in the background. The bookcover of "5 Library terrace, and a photo of Ruth Boreham and Natalie Fergie.

Exploring the Jackie Kay archive

Talk
28 May 2026, 5:30PM to 6:30PM
Photo of Jackie Kay over a background of material from her archive.